No Claim for Payment Upon Withdrawal from a Service Contract
A consumer verbally commissioned an electrician outside the business premises without receiving cancellation instructions. The CJEU ruled that upon subsequent withdrawal, the trader has no claim for remuneration.
A consumer verbally commissioned an electrician off-premises without receiving a statutory notice on the right of withdrawal. After the work was completed, the consumer declined to pay the invoice and withdrew from the contract.
Following the wording of the Consumer Rights Directive, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that the trader has no right to remuneration or compensation, even where costs were incurred, emphasizing the high level of consumer protection.
Businesses concluding contracts off-premises or via distance selling must provide clear withdrawal notices and general terms beforehand. Our office advises both businesses and consumers on drafting compliant terms as well as asserting or defending claims.